Lookalike breeds

Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: how to tell them apart

A Belgian Malinois is lighter and squarer, with a short fawn to mahogany coat and a black mask. A German Shepherd is heavier and longer than it is tall, usually black and tan or sable, often with a longer coat.

German Shepherd
German Shepherd
Belgian Malinois
Belgian Malinois

Not sure which one your dog is? Upload a photo. Our AI compares it with 120 breeds, including both of these, and shows the 3 closest matches in about ten seconds.

Check my dog's breed

German Shepherd vs Malinois: the 5 differences to look for

  1. Body shape. The Malinois is square: its body is about as long as it is tall. The German Shepherd is longer than it is tall, and many have a back that slopes down toward the hips.
  2. Weight. Both stand 22 to 26 inches, but the Malinois is lighter. AKC lists 60 to 80 lb for male Malinois and 65 to 90 lb for male German Shepherds.
  3. Colour. A Malinois is fawn to mahogany with black tips on the hairs, plus a black mask and black ears. A German Shepherd is most often black and tan or black and red with a dark saddle, and can also be sable or solid black.
  4. Coat. The Malinois coat is always short and straight. German Shepherds have a medium coat, and some have a long coat.
  5. Head. The Malinois head looks finer and more chiselled. The German Shepherd has a broader, heavier head.

Size, weight and lifespan

German Shepherd and Belgian Malinois size compared
  German Shepherd Belgian Malinois
Height at the shoulder22 to 26 in22 to 26 in
Weight50 to 90 lb40 to 80 lb
Life expectancy7 to 10 years14 to 16 years

Ranges cover males and females together. Source: the AKC breed standards and breed pages.

Temperament and care, side by side

The American Kennel Club rates every breed from 1 to 5 on the same traits. Highlighted cells show where the two breeds differ by 2 points or more.

AKC trait ratings for the German Shepherd and the Belgian Malinois, 1 to 5
AKC rating (1 to 5) German Shepherd Belgian Malinois
Energy 5 4
Shedding 4 3
Grooming 2 2
Good with young kids 5 3
Good with other dogs 3 3
Barking 3 3
Easy to train 5 5
Needs mental work 5 4
Adapts to change 5 3
Playful 4 3
Affectionate with family 5 3
Open to strangers 3 3
Watchdog 5 4
Drooling 2 1

Which one is right for you?

Both are working dogs with a lot of drive. AKC rates both 5 out of 5 for trainability and gives the German Shepherd 5 for energy against 4 for the Malinois.

The German Shepherd is the easier family dog on paper: AKC rates it 5 out of 5 with young children and for affection, against 3 and 3 for the Malinois. A Malinois needs an experienced owner and a job to do every day. One clear plus for the Malinois: AKC gives it 14 to 16 years against 7 to 10 for the German Shepherd.

Still choosing a breed? The dog breed quiz scores 55 breeds against your home, time and family.

How our AI tells them apart

The dog breed identifier is an image model trained on photos of 120 breeds. It looks at the whole dog at once: head shape, ears, coat, colour and build. You get the 3 closest breeds with a score for each.

If the top two scores are close and they are these two breeds, your dog may be a mix of both, or the photo hides the clues above. Try a second photo from the side, in daylight, with the tail and ears in view. For a firm answer on a mixed dog, a dog DNA test reads the genes instead of the looks.

Sources

German Shepherd vs Malinois: common questions

Is a Belgian Malinois a German Shepherd?
No. The Belgian Malinois is a separate breed from Belgium. It is one of four Belgian herding varieties, together with the Groenendael (Belgian Sheepdog), the Tervuren and the Laekenois.
Which is bigger, a Malinois or a German Shepherd?
They are about the same height, 22 to 26 inches, but the German Shepherd is heavier. Male German Shepherds weigh 65 to 90 lb and male Malinois 60 to 80 lb.
Why do police use the Malinois?
The Malinois is light, fast and very driven, which suits detection and patrol work. AKC rates it 5 out of 5 for trainability.
Which lives longer?
AKC gives the Belgian Malinois 14 to 16 years and the German Shepherd 7 to 10 years.
What is a Malinois and German Shepherd mix called?
A Malinois and German Shepherd mix is sometimes called a Shepinois. Its colour and coat length are the easiest clues to which parent it takes after.

Identify your dog's breed from a photo